How to Pick an SEO Company

by | June 12, 2024

Choosing the right SEO company is a big decision. The right partner can boost your business, while the wrong one can waste your time and money. Let’s break down the steps to help you make the best choice.

Understanding Your SEO Needs

Before you start searching for an SEO company, you need to know what you’re looking for.

Identify Your Goals

Are you aiming to improve rankings for specific keywords, increase organic traffic, or enhance your website’s user experience? Clear goals will help you communicate your needs effectively. For instance, if your primary goal is to boost local visibility, you’ll want to focus on companies that excel in local SEO strategies. On the other hand, if you’re targeting an international market, your goals might include multilingual SEO or international link building.

Assess Your Current SEO Strategy

Look at what you’re currently doing and identify areas for improvement. This will guide you in choosing the right services. Conduct a thorough audit of your current SEO efforts, including your on-page optimization, content quality, backlink profile, and technical SEO aspects like site speed and mobile friendliness. This assessment will reveal gaps and opportunities, helping you determine whether you need a full SEO overhaul or just targeted improvements in specific areas.

Researching Potential Companies

With your needs defined, it’s time to research potential SEO companies.

Look for Experience and Expertise

Choose companies with a proven track record in your industry. Experience with similar businesses can be very beneficial. Look for case studies or client portfolios that showcase their success stories. This demonstrates their expertise and gives you a sense of their strategic approach and the types of results they’ve achieved for businesses like yours.

Check Client Testimonials and Case Studies

These provide insights into the company’s ability to deliver results and handle challenges. Reach out to past clients if possible, to get firsthand feedback on their experience. Client testimonials can reveal important details about the company’s strengths and weaknesses, customer service quality, and overall effectiveness.

Evaluate Services Offered

Ensure the company offers the specific services you need and has expertise in those areas. Whether you need on-page SEO, technical SEO, content marketing, or link building, the company should have proven capabilities in those services. Check if they offer additional services that might benefit your business, such as PPC, social media marketing, or web design, which can provide a more integrated approach to your digital marketing efforts.

Asking the Right Questions

Once you have a shortlist, it’s time to ask the right questions.

Inquire About Their SEO Process

Understanding their approach will give you an idea of how they plan to achieve your goals. Ask about their methods for keyword research, content creation, link building, and technical optimization. A transparent company will be willing to explain their process and provide examples of their work.

Discuss Communication and Reporting

Clear communication is crucial. Make sure their reporting aligns with your expectations. Ask how often they will report on progress, what metrics they will track, and how they measure success. Regular updates and detailed reports will keep you informed and help you understand the impact of their efforts on your business.

Understand Pricing and Contracts

Get clarity on costs and contract terms to avoid surprises later. Some companies offer month-to-month contracts, while others may require a longer commitment. Understand the pricing structure, including any additional fees for extra services or unexpected changes in the project scope. Transparency in pricing is key to establishing trust and ensuring there are no hidden costs.

Considerations for Local vs. Global SEO

Your target market affects the expertise you need.

Local SEO Expertise

If you’re focusing on a local market, find a company with success in local SEO strategies. This includes optimizing your Google My Business profile, managing online reviews, and building local citations. Local SEO experts will have a deep understanding of how to boost your visibility in local search results and attract nearby customers.

Global SEO Strategies

For a broader market, you need a company experienced in global SEO. They should be knowledgeable about international SEO practices, such as hreflang tags, localizing content for different regions, and managing international backlinks. Global SEO experts can help you navigate the complexities of reaching audiences in multiple countries, ensuring your site performs well in various languages and regions.

Due Diligence and Background Check

Before making your final decision, conduct a thorough background check.

Verify Credibility and Reputation

Look for reviews, ratings, and industry recognitions. Check reputable review sites like Clutch, Google My Business, and Trustpilot. Industry awards and recognitions can also indicate a company’s credibility and expertise. A well-respected company will have positive reviews and a strong reputation in the SEO community.

Check for Red Flags

Be wary of promises of immediate results or very low prices, which can indicate black-hat practices. Tactics like keyword stuffing, link farms, and cloaking can result in penalties from search engines. Ensure the company adheres to ethical SEO practices and follows search engine guidelines. Ask for examples of their work and request a clear explanation of their strategies to confirm they use legitimate methods.

Making the Final Decision

Compare your options and choose the best fit.

Compare and Contrast

Look at what each company offers and how it aligns with your needs and budget. Create a comparison chart to evaluate their strengths, weaknesses, and the value they provide. Consider factors like their expertise, service offerings, communication style, and client feedback.

Trust Your Instincts

Sometimes, it comes down to which company you feel most comfortable with. A company that listens to your concerns, understands your goals, and communicates clearly is more likely to be a good partner. Trust your gut feeling and choose the company that feels right for your business.

Establish Clear Expectations and Goals

Before signing any contracts, ensure both parties understand the expected outcomes and timelines. Discuss your goals in detail and agree on the KPIs that will measure success. Clear expectations from the start will help avoid misunderstandings and ensure a productive partnership.


Choosing the right SEO company requires careful consideration. By understanding your needs, doing thorough research, and asking the right questions, you can find a partner that will drive your business forward. Aim for a company that aligns with your goals and can deliver the results you expect. Remember, the goal is to find a company that meets your needs and feels like a true extension of your team, working collaboratively to achieve your business objectives.



We’ll never share your email with anyone else

Recent Articles